top of page
Search

A Five-Letter Word Game You Play by Text, and the Best Starting Words According to the Math

Writer: Textapp
Textapp
Oct 23
5 min read

Updated: Nov 2

Five Letters is the word game inside Games Textapp. It picks a five-letter word, you get six guesses, and every guess comes back with each letter marked green (right letter, right place), yellow (in the word, but somewhere else) or grey (not in the word). If that sounds like Wordle, it is played in that style, and the style is older than most people think. This post covers where the game came from, what information theory says about a first guess, and the best opener for the actual list of answers our game draws from.



Seventy years of guessing five letters


The lineage starts with Jotto, a pen-and-paper game invented in 1955 by Morton M. Rosenfeld. Each player writes down a secret five-letter word, and after every guess the opponent announces only how many letters match, with nothing about position, according to the Wikipedia entry on Jotto. The television show Lingo, the same entry notes, added what makes the modern game click: it revealed whether each matching letter was in the correct position, picked the words itself and limited the guesses.


Then came Wordle. Welsh software engineer Josh Wardle built it, released it publicly in October 2021, and the New York Times bought it on January 31, 2022 for an undisclosed low seven-figure sum, per Wikipedia's Wordle article, which describes the game as "conceptually and stylistically" similar to Jotto and Lingo. The daily puzzle and the shareable grid of coloured squares were new. The guessing mechanic was not.



What a good first guess is actually doing


In February 2022 Grant Sanderson, who makes the 3Blue1Brown videos, published a lesson called Solving Wordle using information theory that treats the first guess as a measurement and scores each possible opener by its expected information, in bits. As Scientific American summarised the approach, one bit is feedback that halves the set of possible answers, so a guess worth 5.89 bits, the magazine's figure for the obscure word "soare", cuts the 2,309 Wordle solutions down to about 1.7 percent of them on average.


Sanderson's first video landed on "crane" as the opener whose simulations averaged the fastest solves, as Notebookcheck reported. A week later he published a follow-up titled "Oh, wait, actually the best Wordle opener is not 'crane'", which goes over a minor bug in the original run. With the fix, the American Mathematical Society's Math Voices digest notes, "salet" was the word that led his program to the right answer in the fewest guesses on average, with a caveat worth keeping: the best strategy for a computer and the best strategy for a human are not the same thing.



Why five-letter words have their own alphabet


The intuition behind all of these openers is letter frequency, and English overall is well measured. Peter Norvig's analysis of the Google Books corpus, English Letter Frequency Counts: Mayzner Revisited, puts E at 12.49 percent of all letters, then T at 9.28, A at 8.04, O at 7.64, I at 7.57, N at 7.23, S at 6.51 and R at 6.28. Position matters too: E is about four times less common as a first letter than elsewhere, T is the most common first letter, and E is the most common last letter.


But a game's answer list is not running text, where "the" and "and" do most of the work. Words of exactly five letters have a different alphabet, and that is what we measured.



Our own numbers: the 910 answers in Five Letters


Five Letters draws its answers from a fixed list of 910 common, family-safe five-letter words. We loaded the list and counted.


  • E appears in 50 percent of the answers, R and A in 40 percent each, T in 34, O and S in 30, L in 28, I in 26.

  • By position: S opens 18 percent of the answers, far ahead of C at 9 and T at 7. R is the most common second letter (15 percent), A the most common third (16 percent), and E the most common fourth (13 percent) and fifth (22 percent).

  • 249 answers, 27 percent, contain a repeated letter.


Against Norvig's text frequencies, S ranks seventh in English as a whole but is the most common opening letter here, T drops from second to fourth, and R overtakes T entirely. A word list has its own rules.


Then we scored every answer as an opener two ways. By coverage, meaning how many of the 910 answers share at least one letter with the guess, the winners are "alert", "later" and "alter", each touching 861 answers, or 94.6 percent. Measured Sanderson's way, by the expected information in the green, yellow and grey pattern, "trace" is the best opener in our list at 6.04 bits, followed by "stare" at 6.00 and "slate" at 5.95. For comparison, "crane" is worth 5.84 bits against our list and "salet" 5.86 (the game accepts it as a guess, though it is not an answer). The vowel-heavy favourite "audio" scores only 4.43 bits, because it says almost nothing about the consonants that separate the answers. If you want one recommendation: start with trace, then stare or slate.



The repeated-letter rule, precisely


This is the rule that trips people up, so here is exactly how Five Letters scores it. First, every letter in the right place is marked green, and that copy of the letter in the answer is used up. Then the remaining letters of your guess are checked left to right: a letter is marked yellow only if the answer still has an unused copy of it, and otherwise it is grey. Green and yellow marks for any letter never outnumber its appearances in the answer, so a guess with two copies that comes back one yellow and one grey means the answer has exactly one, a point the Nerdschalk guide to double letters makes with the same example.


Two worked cases from the game's own scoring. If the answer is "sheep" and you guess "eerie", you get yellow, yellow, grey, grey, grey: two of your three Es found copies, so the answer has exactly two. If the answer is "crane" and you guess "eerie", the last E is green, and because green is settled first it takes the only E, leaving the two earlier Es grey; the R is yellow. Read the marks as a count, not a sequence, and double letters stop being a mystery.



Try it by text


Text Hi to (725) 252-4524 and ask for Five Letters, or any of the other six games, from Blackjack to Trivia. It works on any phone that can text, with no app and no account. Games Textapp is an AI. The first 30 messages are free, then one $9.99 a month subscription covers every Textapp. Text STOP at any time to end messages. Message and data rates may apply. More at textapp.co/apps/games.

Comments


Commenting on this post isn't available anymore. Contact the site owner for more info.
bottom of page